What sets counselling and psychotherapy apart?
The terms counselling and psychotherapy are often used interchangeably, and there is genuine overlap between them. Both involve talking with a trained professional about emotional or psychological difficulties. Both aim to help you understand yourself better and make positive changes in your life.
The distinction between the two is not always clear cut, and practitioners themselves sometimes disagree about where one ends and the other begins. That said, there are some general differences worth understanding if you are considering therapy.
Describe what a client brings to you and find out which counselling approach is most evidence based for their situation.
Try our Counselling Approach Finder free, here on this site →Duration and depth of work
Counselling typically refers to shorter term work. It often focuses on a specific issue or life event: a bereavement, relationship breakdown, work stress or a period of anxiety. The aim is usually to help you work through that particular difficulty and develop practical ways of coping.
Psychotherapy tends to be longer term and may explore deeper patterns in how you think, feel and relate to others. It often looks at how past experiences, including those from childhood, shape your present difficulties.
In practice, these boundaries blur. A counsellor may work with you over an extended period if that is what you need. A psychotherapist may offer focused, time limited support. For many people, the specific approach and therapeutic style will matter more than whether someone calls themselves a counsellor or psychotherapist, though some clients do find the distinction meaningful when choosing a practitioner.
Your situation may be slightly different. ask a question below ↓ and our editorial team will reply with our advice.
Training, qualifications and therapeutic approaches
Both counsellors and psychotherapists undergo rigorous professional training with supervised clinical practice. The length and structure of training programmes varies, but both fields generally require postgraduate level study.
There is no legal requirement in the UK to hold a specific qualification before calling yourself a counsellor or psychotherapist. This makes it essential to verify credentials before beginning therapy. Most reputable practitioners are registered with a professional body such as the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP), the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP) or the National Counselling Society (NCS). These organisations set standards for training, ethics and ongoing professional development. You can search their registers online.
Both counsellors and psychotherapists may draw on different therapeutic approaches, including cognitive behavioural, humanistic, psychodynamic and integrative methods. The type of therapy offered often depends on the practitioner's training and your particular needs.
Choosing what is right for you
Some practitioners with psychotherapy training choose to call themselves counsellors. The word can feel less formal to people seeking help for the first time. Others use both terms depending on the context of their work.
What matters most is finding someone whose approach suits your needs. Some questions worth asking before you begin:
- What training and qualifications do you have?
- Are you registered with a professional body?
- What type of therapy do you offer?
- How long might treatment last?
- What are your fees, and do you offer a sliding scale?
Many therapists offer an initial consultation so you can assess whether you feel comfortable with them. This first meeting can help you decide if their style and approach feel right before committing to ongoing sessions. Good therapy also involves regular review, where you and your therapist discuss how the work is going and whether adjustments are needed.
If you are accessing therapy through the NHS, you will usually be offered a specific type of treatment based on your assessment, though availability varies by area and local resources. Your GP or local NHS Talking Therapies service can explain what is available to you.
Research consistently shows that a good therapeutic relationship is one of the strongest predictors of positive outcomes. If you are unsure where to start, speaking with your GP can help. You can also contact BACP, UKCP or NCS directly to find registered practitioners in your area.
If it's all the same why do counsellors want to call themselves psychotherapists?
In reality, in private practise, both counsellors and psychotherapists do long and short term work.
It is in no way a simple, brief treatment of a behaviour and to describe counselling, in such derisory terms, is like describing a surgeon as a knife wielder.
Here is how I see it...
Counselling is very short term, is mostly listening and the responding is with the words that suggest "why" so-and-so happened, summarising "what" has happened and "what" action now needs to be taken.
Coaching is short-term, is for defined actionable behaviour that involves no risk of psychological damage, structured with "what" has to be done and "how" to achieve each objective.
Psychotherapy is normally long-term to very long-term, is much listening but responding with words that advise "why" something happened, "what" has happened, "what" action must be taken and "how" to achieve the ultimate goal of mental well-being.
For the counselling and coaching, formal qualifications for a charged fee are desirable, but a layperson for donations or just for free in a voluntary capacity should not be impeded so long as there is no risk of psychological damage. For psychotherapy, formal qualifications of several years duration must be achieved and a high professional fee can then be justified.
Unlike other countries, Britain doesn't well distinguish between the technician and the professional. I think we should, thus patients have a hierachy of services available.
We are into physiotherapy business, do check us out.
Counselling and Psychotherapy ?
Please send me the answer in point form.
Thanks
with three main reasons, draw the inherent distinction between counseling and therapy
Erase and start again please before more are mislead.
Since CBT training , this has all changed -Where personal therapy is not seen as important during training. This has certainly led to confusion and blurred boundaries between therapeutic approaches, I believe.
Counselling is good to use on people who do already have good coping strategies in place and will not struggling with the concept of staying positive. Asking some clients in depressive states to stay positive and giving them 'homework' between sessions however can be shaming and counterproductive, leading to a louder inner critical voice. Psychotherapy can often delve into childhood - whether the client says it was good or bad, to understand their human development, behavioural, cognitive and emotional patterns, working its way to the present enabling the client to develop a much better understanding of themselves as a person, eradicating negative self believes/values and strenghtening their adult self.
Counselling is normally over shorter period of time, in CBT it can be up to 12 sessions, whereas psychotherapy can be suited to the needs of the client.
A client who has very little insight or interest in their own wellbeing or safety might with support be able to begin to be curious and and gain insight into such through this experience. It is this dynamic containing function of the therapeutic relationship which allows the client to hopefully begin the establish a secure base within their inner world. Enabling an ability to tolerate anxiety and persecutory feelings. It is at this point that 'behaviour' changes and people can begin to get 'better'.
Semantics aside when the focus is on behaviour modification and giving advice or coaching in relation to specific issues you stop being a Psychodynamic Counsellor. I feel this article is poorly researched and will create further misunderstanding for those trying to make decisions in relation to beginning their own therapy and what they should expect to gain from it.
I do acknowledge that many do not see the two things as the same. In fact it is a hotly debated issue but for some of us the debate is meaningless.
If, psychotherapy is 'a longer-term process of treatment' and counselling is 'a short-term process' why is it that Cognitive Behaviour Therapists (who see themselves as psychotherapists and set themselves apart from counsellors) often do not engage in the long term open-ended work that that many person-centred counsellors do?
Waiting for you to change your website.
Congruence
Ask The Counsellors Guide a question
Ask our editorial team a question and we will reply with our advice. Tell us as much about your situation as you can: the more detail you give, the more useful our answer can be.
You do not need to use your real name. Please do not include your full address, phone number, email address, or the names of other people. We may edit or remove identifying details for privacy and legal reasons.
Comments are moderated before publication.